|
|
European Elections in Malta - compared with those in Ireland
|
10 new countries joined the European Union amd participated in the European elections.
One of these countries was Malta which uses the same electoral system as Ireland.
Malta is entitled to elect 5 members of the European parliament and these members
were elected using STV in a nationwide 5-seat constituency.
Although Ireland and Malta are the only countries where STV is used for all elections,
there are a number of differences in the way the system works in practice.
Malta has developed into a strict two-party system, where only the Nationalist Party (PN)
and the Malta Labour Party (MLP) are represented in the 65-seat Maltese parliament. Also,
Maltese voters are much more faithful to their parties when it comes to transfers.
In Maltese general elections, when votes are transferred from PN or MLP candidates, over
98% of the transferred votes remain with the party. Although this percentage was lower
in the less-important European election, it was still well over 90%.
Another related feature is that the main Maltese parties routinely nominate more candidates
than there are seats available. Given that almost no votes are lost by transfers, this is
a safe tactic. For the 5-seat Malta European election constituency, both the PN and MLP each
nominated 8 candidates. In contrast, for the 13 seats in the Republic,
Fianna Fáil nominated 8 candidates, Fine Gael 6 and Labour 5.
Maltese ballot papers are also designed differently to Irish ones.
In Ireland, candidates are listed alphabetically, regardless of party.
In Malta, candidates are listed alphabetically within party groups.
This means that the 8 PN and 8 MLP candidates are beside each other on the ballot paper.
This may well encourage voters to continue their preferences to candidates of the same party.
The third party in Malta is Alternativa Demokratika (AD), the Maltese Green party.
This party had hoped to make a break-through in the European elections, but although
they polled well above their normal support level, they failed to win a seat.
The following applet shows the Maltese European election result graphically.
The Irish equivalents can be found here.
Notes on using the applet:-
1 use the Next and Zap! buttons to move through the counts
2 use the Restart button to start again
3 move the mouse over the Candidate Vote-Share graph to see a
party's vote percentage through the counts
The following are the results in text format:-
| Surname | First Name(s) | Party | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 |
| Bezzini | Emanuel | app | 717 | 721 | eliminated |
| Zammit | John | app | 39 | 39 | eliminated |
| Cassola | Arnold | ad | 22938 | 23416 | 24424 | 24473 | 24529 | 24621 | 24713 | 24933 | 25147 | 25253 | 25264 | 25598 | 26100 | 26189 | 26359 | 26372 | 27656 | 29013 | unsuccessful |
| Von Brockdorff | Mark | cdp | 64 | 64 | eliminated |
| Lowell | Norman | imp | 1603 | 1619 | eliminated |
| Jones | Cecil Herbert | kul | 66 | 66 | eliminated |
| Attard Montalto | John | mlp | 25287 | 25303 | 25534 | 26162 | 26579 | 26601 | 27053 | 27063 | 27109 | 28418 | 28605 | 28622 | 28675 | 34585 | 45732 | elected, surplus distributed |
| Bedingfield | Glenn | mlp | 13435 | 13439 | 13519 | 13829 | 14062 | 14064 | 14396 | 14397 | 14410 | 16480 | 16931 | 16940 | 16956 | 21978 | eliminated |
| Bonnici | Owen | mlp | 7280 | 7286 | 7329 | 7491 | 7581 | 7584 | 7961 | 7966 | 7976 | eliminated |
| Debobo | Grech Joseph | mlp | 14080 | 14082 | 14147 | 14486 | 14627 | 14631 | 14886 | 14889 | 14895 | 15986 | 16094 | 16101 | 16113 | eliminated |
| Grech | Louis | mlp | 15371 | 15383 | 15442 | 15842 | 15933 | 15939 | 16776 | 16782 | 16788 | 17744 | 18014 | 18032 | 18066 | 22959 | 33293 | 38052 | 38116 | 38173 | elected without reaching the quota |
| Micallef | Robert | mlp | 3390 | 3395 | 3425 | 3658 | 3686 | 3688 | eliminated |
| Mintoff | Lawrence | mlp | 3182 | 3186 | 3216 | eliminated |
| Muscat | Joseph | mlp | 36958 | 36977 | 37073 | 38101 | 38367 | 38375 | 39630 | 39637 | 39669 | 41984 | elected, surplus distributed |
| Busuttil | Simon | pn | 58899 | elected, surplus distributed |
| Casa | David | pn | 8782 | 17608 | 17767 | 17769 | 18120 | 19101 | 19106 | 20246 | 22528 | 22534 | 22534 | 25702 | 30819 | 30831 | 30860 | 30863 | 52693 | elected, surplus distributed |
| Drake | Joanna | pn | 7781 | 11879 | 11948 | 11951 | 12102 | 12830 | 12842 | 13976 | 15099 | 15117 | 15119 | 18122 | 24094 | 24106 | 24129 | 24132 | eliminated |
| Falzon | Michael | pn | 2989 | 3437 | 3472 | 3475 | 3551 | eliminated |
| Friggieri | Joe | pn | 5457 | 7010 | 7083 | 7088 | 7175 | 7886 | 7893 | 8521 | 9544 | 9556 | 9556 | 12113 | eliminated |
| Spiteri Bailey | Ian | pn | 3137 | 4020 | 4061 | 4061 | 4095 | 4426 | 4431 | eliminated |
| Tabone | Anton | pn | 5439 | 5746 | 5803 | 5808 | 5908 | 6161 | 6162 | 6615 | eliminated |
| Tedesco Triccas | Roberta | pn | 5204 | 6449 | 6522 | 6523 | 6638 | 6956 | 6962 | 7715 | 9328 | 9338 | 9339 | eliminated |
| Bonnici | Nazzareno | ind | 183 | 185 | eliminated |
| Farrugia | Carmelo | ind | 3119 | 3131 | 3304 | 3308 | eliminated |
| Iwueke Damian | Chukwuemeka | ind | 153 | 157 | eliminated |
| Sciberras | Christopher | ind | 24 | 24 | eliminated |
| Zammit | Victor | ind | 145 | 146 | eliminated |
Party codes:-
app,Alpha - Partit Politiku
ad,Alternativa Demokratika
cdp,Christian Democratic Republican
imp,Imperium Europa
kul,Kul Ewropa
mlp,Malta Labour Party
pn,Partit Nazzjonalista
ind,Indipendenti
Go here for more information on Maltese elections.
|